When faced with deteriorating weather this weekend, we were faced with the decision to either continue camping or pack up and head to a cabin. I wondered, does abandoning the camping in favor of the cabin make you less of an outdoorsman? My answer might surprise you.
This past Friday, some friends and I left San Diego for Idyllwild, California to do some car camping, drinking and hiking (in that order) on the last weekend of freedom for one of the guys before he is officially put on lock down while waiting for the birth of his first child due mid-March. It was the first time that this group of guys had gotten together since we did Mt. Whitney last year. I was stoked.
Half the group left San Diego in time to claim a campsite at San Jacinto State Park campground and get set up before dark. The others (myself included) left a little later and didn’t arrive until dark. Once we got there, we headed straight for JoAnn’s, a local bar/restaurant which is our traditional spot. After cheeseburgers and a couple pale ales, we headed back to the campsite to set up our tents, make a fire and enjoy several more beers. The weather was absolutely perfect for a campfire. Little to no wind with temps in the low 40’s just as the weather forecast predicted. After we burned through our wood and a good chunk of the beer, we hit the sack. I slept as well as I had in a long time.
The next morning we slept in and waited for our last friend to arrive before making omelets and gearing up for our hike to the summit of Tahquitz Peak via the South Ridge Trail, a 7.2 mile roundtrip hike with a pretty healthy elevation gain. Like everything I’ve done up there, I thought the hike was fantastic. We took a winding dirt road to the South Ridge trailhead at 6,480 feet. I hesitate to disclose this fact, but it’s on the Tom Harrison topo map. There was an awesome yellow post campsite next along the dirt road just short of the trailhead that looked great. We all agreed that it would be our campsite for our next trip (we even contemplated driving back to the campground to relocate our stuff to the South Ridge yellow post site, but thought better of it).

(One of the many views from the South Ridge Trail)
Again, the weather forecast called for patchy fog, partly cloudy skies with temps in the 30’s. Believe or not, I would rather hike in the 30 degree weather than 80 degree weather so I was excited for the forecast. Despite the forecast, we enjoyed a healthy amount of sunshine because we stayed above the cloud cover for most of the hike making for interesting views along almost the whole trail which track the south ridge (its namesake) to the peak. After enjoying some amazing sandwiches on the summit we hightailed it back to the car with few, if any, breaks on the way back down.

(Old decommissioned fire lookout on Tahquitz Peak)
When we arrived back at our campsite, we noticed that the weather was not looking great. As the forecast predicted, it looked like it could start raining or snowing at any moment. It was about 2:30pm and we had a decision to make. We could either go buy a bunch of firewood and ingredients to make dinner at the campsite or we could use the keys to a cabin and relocate our stuff there. At first, no one wanted to be the wimp in the group to advocate for the cabin, but my friend who found a sizable hole in his sleeping bag finally spoke up and voted for the cabin. Another vote for the cabin soon followed. Myself and another guy voted to continue camping leaving the 5th guy to make the call. We all knew what he wanted but he didn’t seem to want to be the tie breaking vote. We let him off the hook and decided to pack up and head over to the cabin.
As we began breaking down our tents, it began to barely drizzle ever so slightly. The proponents of the cabin began to tout their good foresight while us camping advocates were left to shamefully agree that it was probably the right call.
After relocating to the cabin a short distance away, the rain had not yet materialized so we were able to hang outside. We busted out the washers game and our coolers and essentially did the exact same thing that we would have done at the campground. After a couple hours, it was time for dinner. Instead of cooking over the campfire as we had planned, we opted for Idyllwild Pizza in town which is also one of the best food spots in Idyllwild. After devouring appetizers, pizza and more beer, we headed back to the cabin. By now, it was about 7:30pm and a mixture of rain and snow began falling. Admittedly, this would have but a huge buzzkill into our camping. Mid-30’s with wind and rain is absolutely the worst possible weather. We definitely would have been stuck in our tents from that point on. It continued to lightly rain/sleet/snow the rest of the night off and on. We had made a good decision.
So, this all leads me back to the point of this article (yes, there actually is one). Being one of the two votes for camping, I continued to make fun of my friends a little bit for bailing on camping in favor of the cabin all while knowing that it was the right call. Growing up in the Chicago area, I know first-hand that mid-30’s with rain flat out sucks. That night, I came to the conclusion that crashing in a cabin in the woods made us no less outdoorsy than stewing in tents in a state park campground. While suffering sure has its place in certain outdoor pursuits, car camping is not one of them. It’s not like we were on some epic adventure that we cut short because of a little rain. I decided that it’s best not to take yourself too seriously while car camping. The point of the trip was to enjoy the company of good friends before the impending fatherhood of one of my hiking partners. Mission accomplished.

(Tahquitz Peak, 8,846 feet)